Man, am I glad I got these boots/shoes. I REALLY was worried that I'd NEVER find something that was perfect for me. 2 months of wearing them, water, rain, cold, heat perfect timing in between winter and spring. DRY feet - odor not bad at all. I use products to reduce the odor but STILL if you have bought similar shoes - you know how you can do anything and the shoes still stink. Not these guys - I thought they would. Anything that claims waterproof means not a lot of air but I've used products from the start and they are still odor free. No signs of wear yet after 2 months - VERY comfortable and I had horrible feet before this. I DO wear arches in them to fine tune my foot. I WILL buy these again when they weat down - so freaking happy to find something that works. One note: I chose to buy a size one size more WIDE than I usually do. I cant underestimate the impact and wealth of benefit this has given me. TRY IT. CheersI spent a lot of time trying to find a light weight waterproof x wide shoe. This is without a doubt the best ones I could find on Amazon or anywhere else! When I first got them I wish they were a little wider but they broke in pretty fast and are really comfortable. I have had them for a couple months and they are still in good shape and not falling apart. Just skip the wide and get the X wideI wear a 13 Wide. I ordered a 13 Wide but should have ordered a 13 Extra Wide instead. They are comfortable, but snug. Super snug. I feel them squeezing the sides of my feet. The material is very thin, like a watersock. Maybe if I wore some really thin socks they would fit better, but I’m gonna wear them in and ride it out because I got a good price on them.Overall this is a nice shoe, if you have normal or narrow feet, I'm sure they will work out for you. For me, I have wide feet and the widest size of these were very narrow. Even trying them on for 1 minute, my feet were pinched. Again, overall a nice looking shoe, just not for wide feet.Good shoes, a little narrow being the extra wide. Not completely waterproof but definitely water resistant.Nice shoe, well made. Comfortable but narrow.It's almost impossible to get them on without a shoehorn.Shoe quality is far superior to what you pay. I don't know how they're able to do it, but I'm all in on this product.